![]() |
|---|
|
Dear Tim: I share your puzzlement. Why so many Asian Ams care for the "model minority" praise had puzzled me. !44 years after the "all men are created equal" declaration, whilte women couldn't vote. Think who those white women were. They were no less than the mothers, wives, sisters, and daughters of the politicians in power at the time. If the politicians could discriminate against their own mothers, wives, sisters and daughter, what made some Asian Ams believe being praised as model minority would mean no discrimination?
Please try to limit your comments to about 150 words. You'll probably get more people to read them. Thanks. SB Back || Post a follow-up message || Manager only
On July 4th, we celebrate the blessings of liberty which we enjoy as
Americans. Let's all display a flag, shall we?
Patriotism is "love and devotion to country. The questions are how we
love it and how we express our devotion."
There is a great article in Time magazine by Peter Beinart on patriotism
(July 7 issue). I can't do it justice by summarizing it. Nevertheless, I'll try
with the aim to entice you to read the article itself. He wrote and I
paraphrase liberally:
American patriotism wears tow faces. Conservatives prefer the
patriotism of affirmation. Liberals choose the patriotism of dissent.
Conservatives think that being born into a nation is like being born into
a family. You love it because it is yours. Liberals think patriotism is a
struggle to narrow the gap between American ideals and America's
reality. To conservatives, the devotion to America must come first,
struggle to improve it is secondary. To liberals, America must earn our
devotion by making good on its ideals.
Both brands of patriotism have defects. Celebrating America too
unabashedly risks becoming self-righteous and turn patriotism into
nationalism. However, loving America purely because of its ideals could
lead to switching allegiance to other nations too easily.
America needs a mixture of both brands, because love of country
requires both affirmation and criticism.
Many Asian Americans are personal embodiments of this ideal
mix. We give America our primary allegiance*. At the same time, we are
engaged in a great struggle prodding America to fulfill its core value --
equal opportunity for all Americans.
Please display a flag. July 4th is affirmation time.
Commets are welcome at
http://www.80-20educationalfoundation.org/politicaledu/posterboard.asp
Warmest regards,
S. B. Woo
President, 80-20 Educational Foundation, Inc.
* What if a naturalized citizen still has strong feelings for his/her old
country? That is quite OK, so long as he/she gives first allegiance to
America. America is a great and wise nation. It knows that people who
can forget their old country over one naturalization ceremony could easily
forget America the next moment.